Thursday, September 18, 2008

Socialized Medicine is Bad for America

For more by Scott Martin, visit Conservatism Today.

There are plenty of good reasons why socialized health care would be a disaster for America that have been covered by many people. From lack of choices, to poor quality, to waiting lines, to increase in government control over our lives, and on and on. I'd rather illustrate my biggest reason for opposing socialized medicine with a personal story. To me, socialism of any kind kills the American spirit.

Six years ago, a series of events changed the course of my life. I am fully convinced that I would not be the person I am today had they not occurred, and had I not responded to them the way I did. Let me start somewhere near the beginning.

I was 26-years old and working as a bill collector in 2001; I was pretty good at the job and made a good living, but I hated it. In the past few years I had gone from being a GM at McDonald's to the same job with Arby's to a short-lived stint in financial planning to this. I had done well at every job I had ever had, but had eventually set all my bridges ablaze like General Sherman on his march. It was at this time that my wife and I made the decision that I should go back to college to do what I always should have been doing, which is writing for a living.

What does this have to do with socialized medicine? Hang with me a minute. When I quit my job to go back to school, I lost my health insurance. I went to my old financial planning company (which was affiliated with AIG, of all places) and got an application for health insurance. And then I signed up for classes. And that application sat on my desk. And it sat. And it sat.

I went back to school, and was enjoying my learning like never before. And still that application for health insurance sat on my desk. Why? Certainly not because my wife didn't remind me to fill it out and send it in often enough. Perhaps, because as someone highly suited for the (now deceased) field of journalism, I don't do anything until a solid deadline is looming. Perhaps because I was young and felt good and saw no reason to waste money on something that I wasn't going to need in the near future. Either way, on my desk the application sat.

Eight months after losing my insurance as an employee, I awoke in the middle of the night. I couldn't move. I had this godawful pain in my stomach, and even breathing hurt. I awoke my wife, and it took us about 20 minutes to get me in the car to go to the hospital. I will never forget the pain I experienced for the rest of that night, nor the lessons that were to come from it.

At the hospital, we learned I needed to have my gall bladder removed. It was the size of a baseball, the doctor said. We told him I had no insurance, and since this is America, I was treated anyways. He told us we would be looking at around $10,000 for the procedure, and we were in no position to decline. 10K was not something we could readily afford, but in this case we would have to liquidate my wife's 401K. We would make it. And we had no choice.

I'm not sure exactly when we got the final bill, but the $10,000 figure had somehow become $32,000. I do remember laying in the hospital, recovering, and hearing Sean Hannity on the radio talking about socialized health care.

In my vicodine-addled state, I still recall thinking for a fleeting moment that if only we had socialized medicine in the United States, I wouldn't be worried about having to quit school and get a job. In this drug-induced state, I was tempted by the illusion that is socialism of any kind, and that, more and more, is found in today's liberalism.

But almost immediately my mind found release from the temptation. I asked myself some questions:

Who's fault is this? Clearly, it was my fault, and only my fault, that I was not insured. I had put off something in favor of spending the money on something else. I had made a choice. And a bad one, indeed.

Why should the American taxpayer pay for my stupidity? Why should the doctor? Why should anyone, involuntarily? There was no rational answer to these questions. I needed to pay it myself, or I needed some voluntary help.

What country did I live in? The good-old US of A. We Americans are known for overcoming difficult situations, for our goodness to those in need and for the opportunity we have to make of our lives whatever we are able to freely do. I had no reason to despair. This would be a minor setback at worst.

So I made a plan. As a former bill collector, I began negotiations with the hospital, and learned that I should be able to get the bill cut in half. With my abilities and knowledge of the system, I should actually be able to do more. I prayed a lot to find a solution. Through the whole process, my wife and I continued to give above and beyond the Biblical tithe (more than 10% of our income) to charity, as we had done for a couple of years. We never stopped believing that there was a better way out.

After a few months, I thought I was going to be able to settle my bill for about $14,000. That seemed a small price to pay for my mistake, and was almost exactly what the hospital would have received had I been insured. (Insurance companies pay far less than the actual billing cost of any procedure.) But, at the last moment, the hospital suggested I apply for a financial hardship.

Let me tell you, there was no hardship, other than my own stupidity. My wife earned enough money that I could afford to go to school and not have to work. Yet our savings didn't reflect my wife's new-found increase in income. But, believing we had been given another shot at this, I filled this application out immediately. Less than one week later I was notified that a private charity, a church I was not affiliated with, had paid our bill in full. It was, literally, a gift from God.

And I saw that my wife and I had helped bring it about. We never wavered in our belief, we never stopped being charitable, and we never gave up on our conservative ( personal freedom-based) outlook on life. In that fleeting moment where I considered succumbing to the easy secuction of socialism, I nearly lost what made me a free human being. I nearly lost my belief in God as the gaurantor of my prosperity and my well-being, and gave it over to man. But I didn't. It made me stronger when I rejected it. And God gave me the way out of my problem when I trusted in Him.

And this is where the Hillary's and the Obama's and the Biden's don't understand what is unique about America. They preach community, and a giving spirit, but they believe government should do this, not themselves as free people. They would, either unknowingly or out of thirst for power over our lives, destroy community in America.

We have seen in the past week that Obama and Biden talk the talk, but even though they earn 2-3 times more than my family does, they give 20 times less than we do. They don't walk the walk. That's what socialism does to people, it tells us that government is our master, and that government meets needs, not free people under God.

But they are wrong. The United States of America is the most giving country in the world, because of our freedom. That would die forever with the adoption of socialized medicine.

Alexander Hamilton once said, "A nation which can prefer disgrace to danger is prepared for a master, and deserves one!"

This realization has changed my life. I took control of it, and began planning to be more than I thought I could be. When I graduated this Spring, I resisted the easy choice of getting a job at a newspaper making a minimum salary and working for a master who would control what I could express. I'm an American, and my rights come from God, as established in our founding documents. I can make it myself, with God's help, and while doing so I can give to help others who truly can't make it by themselves. And so I have.

Socialized medicine might be OK for the Brits and the French and the Canadians. Their Constitutions don't guarantee freedom under God. They have spent most of the last century preparing themselves for a master, and they are well suited for one.

But it is my belief that Americans are not yet pussified enough to think that they need government to make them whole. The American spirit, that gift of God and of a mostly-free country, is alive and well. And I trust and pray that we will prove that to the rest of the world once again, and reject the rest of the world's desire that we bow to a government under the leadership of an Obamessiah who promises to right all our wrongs, but doesn't explain how it will be the destruction of us as a free nation. Instead, we will continue to not-so-bitterly cling to a government of and for the free people of the United States of America, under God.


  1. YES YES YES YES !!!

    You are so right!
    That's MY America, the traditional values, to which we must come back!

    I just (a few minutes ago) wrote in another blog (desert conservative) the following:

    NObama's/Biden's socialistic ideas are a spiral: more taxes - more spending - more “social gifts” for the new “breed of liberal/socialistic voters”, which want the goverment to be responsible for their whole life - more taxes are needed - more spending - again more money for the new “breed” - need more taxes - and so on.

    We must come back to the traditional American values, back to the American spirit!

    Lean government, which needs less money because of less duties and obligations - people have more money in their pockets and then people will help others who are in need! They will rather help personally than paying higher taxes. Everybody is responsible for himself, helping people, who are in need and standing united to the community and the country - that are (in my eyes) some of the most important traditional American values.

    BTW: I read about a study (sorry, don’t have the link to the study) of a Democrat who hoped to find out, that the Democrats are very charitable people but -unfortunately for himself- he found out, that in all income groups and social levels people who were connected to the Republicans are much more charitable than the Democrats.

    You can also read about all these socialistic ideas and the results at my website where I write about the election from the sight of an immigrant from Germany - a country that realized Obama's ideas decades ago with results, the American citizens wouldn't like.

  2. We have to stick together the next few weeks to prevent this lunatic from seizing the White House! Keep up the good work.

  3. Bravo!! and Amen!! Being a person with an ongoing,longtime chronic disease, I'm proud that I have managed it on my own. Very little insurance money used. Keep up the good work and Thank You!

  4. The problem I have with this is that it assumes that anyone who doesn't have health insurance is at fault when they get sick.

    But here's the thing. I don't have health insurance, and it's not because I'm wasting my money on frivolous expenses; I don't even pay for cable television.

    Perhaps you could have afforded health insurance, but many of us can't.

    Further, I know for a fact, that the founder of this blog could not get health insurance to cover the actual reasons he needs it. He's disqualified due to pre-existing conditions. As am I, as is my father.

    We have to reign in health costs, and bringing everyone into the system -- healthy and sick -- is the only way to do this.

    Your assumption here seems to be that people without health insurance are simply being irresponsible with their money, but that's not the case. I eat of the dollar menu, I live on Raman noodles. I have no television or other luxury expenses, but I still can't afford health insurance.

    Why shouldn't I be able to buy into a government plan that could help lower the costs? Obama's plan doesn't force anyone to buy into the government health insurance program, but it does give them that option.

    Meanwhile, McCain's plan actually taxes businesses on their healthcare. Explain to me how that is supposed to improve our situation.

  5. Big Blue -

    "We have to reign in health costs, and bringing everyone into the system -- healthy and sick -- is the only way to do this."

    That is the exact opposite way to bring down expenses. As demand increases, so does price.

    And you don't need to worry if you can't afford it. You'll never have to pay for any care you receive as the system stands now. We'll be paying it for you through higher prices.

    The system is a mess. Most of the mess comes from people thinking they have some "right" to the services of others. I don't know how to fix it at this point, but the way not to fix it is with a system that adds to government power at the expense of freedom.

  6. If America had a universal, single payer insurance system (which is not "socialized medicine" by the care providers, doctors, nurses, hospitals...all still private actors here in Canada) you would have been paying premiums through your taxes all along, your coverage wouldn't have stopped when you went back to school and you would never even have seen a bill, never mind having to negotiate with the hospital to find a way to pay it.

    Single payer insuarnce in Canada and Europe keeps health care costs there to halfor less what they are in the US, administrative costs are a fraction of the American model and outcomes are as good, or better. Don't believe those horror stories about universal health care. It's empty fearmongering from the corporatists who value their profits more than your health.

  7. OK Scott suppose you had that insurance and you were still billed $32000 because, your insurance company discovered you had gone to the doctor six months earlier, before you had insurance and complained of indigestion, and they are not going to pay.

    How proud and self righteous would you feel about negotiating and paying your own way through this bill after you and your wife who, let's say are 54 years old , are self-employed, live in NJ and have to pay $1500- a month for your individual health plan?

    That is what it costs my husband and I for health insurance in NJ and I have been in the scenario I have described above to you.

    My solution for Americas health plan is to make every company stop paying for employee healthcare (they give you a salary for your time, pull yourself up by your bootstraps and get your own policy), to stop using my taxes to pay for federal and state employees,( I am paying for theirs yet I can not afford my own) to stop the use of Medicare and Medicaid, (which I also pay for) and now put every American on a level playing field.

    Once they saw the costs and the rip offs that the health insurance industry is allowed to get away with to those that have to pay their own way, you would see how every American would be screaming bloody murder for the gov to give them what you call "socialized medicine" or some sort of laws to stop this insanity.

  8. If you are looking for tour&travels related information, you can scan the resource page of and get travel related links on the resource section of the website.

  9. Why don't they talk to people like me and you and other ex-pats who have lived under both systems and let us tell them what we think. You're right. A lot of people don't know what their talking about. If you listened to the group against it you would think that everyone in the U.K. is dropping dead, the NHS is so bad. Ridiculous!

    I had planned a post on this issue in the next couple of weeks and I may link to your post, okay?
    Free Trial Intraday Tips || Free Trial Commodity Tips || Free Trial Mcx Tips

  10. Healthcare is an issue that has plagued the nation for years. And rightly so. Any service that is on track to consuming around 40 percent of the gross national product of the largest economy in the world by the year 2050, will be hard to overlook. Health expenditures in the U.S. reached nearly 2.6 trillion in 2010, 10 times the amount spent in 1980 and is expected to grow even faster in the near future. Worse yet, there were 50.7 million Americans without health insurance in 2010, and this number is exponentially increasing as the recession continues to put people out of work and families continue to cut insurance to cut costs. Skyrocketing prices for prescriptions and health insurance are forcing many to delay receiving medical care, or even denying it. As employers are refusing to pay their share of premiums for employer-sponsored coverage, millions of workers are losing their coverage. These factors should be plenty to incite drastic changes in the way this government cares for the people.

  11. Your Information was absolutely right, i appreciate your Post. Looking for more updates from your side. Thanks. Good JOB. Keep it up.

    Mcx Tips | Commodity Trading

  12. You have done an excellent job, Keep it up. Thanks for sharing

    Website for day traders

    Intraday tips for day traders. Our Nse tip work in 60 minute. for free trial visit:
    or send sms TRIAL TO 56767 or TRIAL TO 98 70 80 1717

  13. This comment has been removed by the author.

  14. Whenever you think to start trading in stock market you must have to think twice; because if you take any wrong decision you have loose your all capital. And in order to taking the right choice you can depend on commoditytipsadvisory to take Sure Shot Mcx Tips . The best probability to get the benefits of intraday commodity tips free guidelines that not only save you from the loss but also you can gain a hug profit in Indian share market tips.

  15. Today Everyone want to earn the money but Is it possible or not yes it is possible now because the trading style has changed. This time every person easily invest in share market and they can also easily invest in complete commodity. commoditytradingcall can play the important role in your investment because we provide tips like Intraday Trading Tips It is daily tips also we offer Intraday Mcx Tips. There are lots of commodity plan and it can change your trading style.

  16. Nice blog and very informative. It provide us very important point for share market and commodity market. Also its most important for investors.
    Thank you,
    Commodity Tips

  17. This is the Best Blog. If you want to invest in MCX/Commodity Market so gold Silver is best for you.
    MCX Gold Call

  18. Excellent post about "Socialized Medicine is Bad for America"

    Silver Positional Calls || Sure Commodity Tips

  19. waoo nice post regarding "Socialized Medicine is Bad for America"


    Silver Sureshot Call

  20. Wow, absolutely fantastic blog. I am very glad to have such useful information. Thanks. For more information visit

    NIOS Admission 10th
    NIOS Admission 12th